Synopsis of Comments to Tynwald regarding Representation

Here below is a synopsis of the comments that I submitted regarding representation at Isle of Man General Election 2016 and how this can be improved.

I enclosed a spreadsheet of the election result from September 22nd 2016, The spreadsheet covers all the results from all the constituencies in the Isle of Man. I submitted as shown in my example below the results from Rushen constituency where I stood to demonstrate total representation in Rushen.

Total votes balloted in Rushen constituency 5767 as per Manx Radio
Turnout in Rushen officially 58.2%

Leo Cussons  Independent  331 5.7%
James Hampton  Independent  1033 17.9%
Mark Kemp  Independent  1104 19.1%
Laurence Skelly  Independent  1212 Elected 21.0%
Juan Watterson  Independent  2087 Elected 36.2%

Census 2016 give the total number of residents at 6,977
Total number of resident registered voters 5767
Difference of 1210
That lowers the turn out to 45.47%

From the turnout, two candidates were elected with 57.2% of the vote

That means that 42.8% of people that voted are not represented in any form

Most worrying is that from the total number of residents in Rushen only 26.03% (57.25% of 45.47%) are represented. This clearly is not very effective form of representation.

In the short term, I propose that voting should be made compulsory as the sheer cost of elections makes them ineffective if they are not used by all residents. This would also mean that everyone is involved in society. There are many places in the world where this has proven to be successful. Australia is a good example of this.

Secondly, we need to move some sort of proportional representation where all candidates are members of political parties. The total vote in the Isle of  Man for each party secures the number of seats in Tynwald. This way you a have a true representation of all the people in the Isle of Man and their will.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.